|
|
|
 |
theStrad - February 2010,
p.80 |
|
 |
| review by Tully Potter |
|
This lovely,
eminently
listenable live recording serves to introduce an outstanding young
Italian string trio consisting of the siblings Barbara, Giada and Klaus
Broz. In their naturalness, unobtrusive virtuosity and close
ensemble
they remind me of the original line-up of the Leopold Trio. It is 23
years since Dmitri Sitkovetsky published his version of Goldberg
Variations for this instrumentation and recorded it with Gérard
Caussé and Misha Maisky. Bruno Giuranna tells me that he
started modifying that version but soon foun he was making a new one,
wich is used here. I find the result more convincing than the
Sitkovetsky, although some parts are inevitably almost identical.
Var. 19 is played in
pizzicato and, where four voices are involved, Giuranna resorts to
double-stops on violin and viola. In var.23 the violin has scales in
third and sixths.
The playing is
so
good,
so unified and so consistently beautiful in tone that is amazing to
realise we are listening to a concert performance. The initial
statement of the theme is just a little stiff to start with, but the
players soon relax. The recording quality is as sympathetic as the
musicianship.
|
|
|
 |
Classic
FM
-
January
2010, p. 59 |
|
 |
| review by John
Brunning |
|
|
This
recording of the Goldberg Variations in a version for string trio is
further proof of how Bach's music is apparently impervious to the
instruments it's played on.
|
|
|
 |
Classical Music, Rhingold Publication
- the 21th November
2009,
p. 58 |
    |
 |
| review by Phil Sommerich |
|
|
There
are
countless
arrangements
of
Bach’s meditative epic but
this one for string trio by the violist Bruno Giuranna goes to the
front rank. Trio Broz – three siblings- share the melodic
weight, the
three lines simple yet using the strings’ dynamic shading to create a
sense of conversation, all in stunning hi-def audio quality.
|
|
|
 |
Amadeus - March 2008, p. 87 |
    |
 |
| review by Emilia Campagna |
|
Thanks
to their speculative character, the Goldberg Variations, a monumental
page in harpsichord repertoire of Bach, have been performed on
several transcriptions, for solo instruments (such as the harp) as
well for chamber ensemble. The version for string trio by the Russian
violinist Dimitry Sitkovetsky knew for example certain luck; in
addition to this now, for the same ensamble, we can hear the
transcription by Bruno Giuranna, which is actually not recently,
because he wrote it for his string trio - Trio d'archi Italiano -,
but it never landed circuits of publishing and discography, and
remained fast unknown. Now the CD of Velut Luna let us hear this
interesting and successful transcription which distributes the
counterpoint in the sounds of the violin, the viola and the cello
(often actually we can see three lines in the score for harpsichord) with a new
plasticity and transparency for the complex composition,
in several moments extraordinarily vivid and immediate. The
Trio Broz
prepared the execution under the guidance of the same Giuranna and
thus the interpretation accurately reflects the aesthetic idea of the
transcriber: far from the logic of philology and the "Baroque
sonar," the execution of the Trio Broz seems to tend towards the
classical idea of purity, of perfect balance, in a bright and anodyne
treatment of the complex musical material.
|
|
|
 |
Il
Sole
24
ore
- Sunday the 8th February 2009,
p.38 |
|
 |
| review by Carla Moreni |
|
|
Bach
had a student named Goldberg. He was protected by Count von
Keyserling, who was suffering of insomnia. So the young musiciann
asked Bach a speculative and seductive composition for harpsichord,
that he could play during the night. The history of the Goldberg
Variations is known. But now goes on: a legendary Maestro of viola,
Bruno Giuranna, born in Milan, famous throughout the world,
transcribed for string trio the Goldberg. He gave it to a wonderful
young italian Trio (although the name "Broz" is deceiving)
formed by three siblings, grew up in the music between Verona,
Salzburg, Rome and Fiesole. The album, world premiére
recording, gives a rare pleasure. Bach sounds magnificent: more
singing, more colours, thanks to this version for strings. Bravo Trio
Broz: a lot of poetry.
|
|
|
 |
Corriere della Sera - Sunday the 11th
January 2009, p. 42 |
|
 |
review by Enrico Girardi
|
|
|
Like
all
'speculative'
music
of Bach, the Goldberg
Variations are
adaptable at a transcription that, if done according to the book,
shows in another light some aspects of the original score. And this
is the case of this transcription for string trio written by Bruno
Giuranna and performed by Trio Broz, that is the siblings Barbara
(violin), Giada (viola) and Klaus (cello). A beautiful disc also
because - as the transcriber wrote - the variations, especially those
for two or three voices, are designed for different instruments in
the writing of Bach. In
addition, the use of different instrumental
techniques gives to the famous series a variety of timbres
unthinkable only with the harpsichord. It works even thanks the
excellent harmony betweeen the musicians. Score and parts
available
on www.brunogiuranna.com.
|
|
|
 |
Classic
Voice - December 2008, p. 64 |
     |
 |
| review by Giancarlo
Cerisola |
|
|

To
alleviate the seriousness that hovers around Bach and these famous
rigorous geometric variations, you usually simplify the genesis of
the work telling that it were intended for the harpsichord of his
pupil Johann Gottlieb Godberg: he could alleviate the sleepless
nights of Count von Keiserling by performing. Actually, this
transcription seems made to take awake even who wanted to take a nap,
this is the vitality that springs from unraveling the dense
contrapunt, much clearly than possible with the keyboard alone.
Following the example of the Bach and his contemporaries - who
created masterpieces by transcribing own or other people's works -
the Goldberg Variations were during the centuries repeatedly
transcribed for various organic. Among the most original ones there
is certainly this version, by the violinist Bruno Giuranna, member
with Gulli and Caramia of the unforgettable
Trio
Italiano
d'Archi,
whose
possible successors seem to be Barbara and her siblings Giada
and Klaus, with an interpretation full of young vitality.
|
|